1986—John Eliot Gardiner-G

Best overall?  One of, surely

A—Ky—Reverent, measured, stately

A—Ch—Sylvia McNair; best gentle, unaffected, angelic, soaring; does she ever take a breath?

A—Gl—Joyous, crisp; good brass

A—LT—Diana Montague; Vocalise; great voice, flutelike sound; fast, fun orchestra can’t convince her to smile even once

A—Gr—Assertive, grave

A—DD—Great voices; smooth, no battle

A—QT—Painful, reproachful, stumbling, but just a trifle too smooth to stagger; hymnlike

A—Qu—Individual voices heard well, but still blend nicely; jaunty, upbeat

A—JC— Same

A—CSS—Clear articulation of voices; jolly, upbeat; good climactic cadence

A—Cr—Exultant, driving rhythm; chickens come through second time

A—Et—Sylvia McNair; best; gentle, unaffected, tender, dreamy; 1 to 1 love song; her sound is intimate, her jumps are clean, her breaths are imperceptible, and there is not a trace of an edge in her high notes; no one is allowed to speak during her cadenza

A—S—Assertive, confident; soaring sopranos at “Dominus Deus Sabbaoth”; really good brass

A—H—Crisp, clear, all voices have their say

A—B—Jolly, jaunty, everybody’s smiling, all voices come through; detached strings at B

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *