PREVIOUS: VALUE JUDGEMENTS
13 intimate “Christe eleison” (standouts in bold)
Edith Mathis (Gönnenwein), Sylvia McNair (Gardiner) (“best”), Edith Wiens (Shaw), Kathleen Battle (Levine), Barbara Schlick (Kuentz), Arleen Auger (Bernstein), Bozena Harasimowicz (Vad) (“most excellent”), Patricia Petibon (Christie), Valentina Farcas (Matt), Camilla Tilling (McCreesh), Natalie Dessay (Langreé), Gillian Keith (Christophers), Carolyn Sampson (Suzuki) (“excellent”)
19 rambunctious “Laudamus te” (standouts in bold)
Hertha Töpper ( Fricsay) (“best”), Helen Donath (Gönnenwein), Janet Perry (Karajan), Della Jones (Welser-Möst), Lynne Dawson (Hogwood), Monika Frimmer (Neumann), Bernarda Fink (Corboz), Anne Sofie von Otter (Solti), Ibolya Verebics (Rilling 1991), Dominique Labelle (Parrott), Anne Sophie von Otter (Marriner), Katarzyna Suska (Vad), Evelyne Brun (Girolami), Lynne Dawson (Christie), Stella Doufexis (Bolton), Véronique Gens (Langreé), Olivia Vermeulen (Suzuki), Sophie Harmsen (Bernius) (“excellent version”); Anke Vondlung (Arman)
26 intimate “Et incarnatus est” (standouts in bold)
Irmgard Seefried (Jochum), Maria Stader (Paumgartner), Helen Donath (Davis), Sylvia McNair (Gardiner) (“best”), Arleen Auger (Bertini), Edith Wiens (Shaw), Felicity Lott (Welser-Möst), Kathleen Battle (Levine), Barbara Schlick (Kuentz), Barbara Schlick (Neumann), Audrey Michael (Corboz), Arleen Auger (Bernstein) (“close 2nd”), Christiane Oelze (Rilling 1991) (“another gem with McNair & Auger”), Christiane Oelze (Herreweghe), Nancy Armstrong (Parrott), Kiri te Kanawa (Marriner), Bozena Harasimowicz-Haas (Vad), Viktoria Loukianetz (Halász), Patricia Petibon (Christie), Valentina Farcas (Matt), Camilla Tilling (McCreesh), Gabriele Hierdeis (Hempfling), Gillian Keith (Christophers), Carolyn Sampson (Suzuki), Sarah Wegener (Bernius); Christina Landshamer (Arman)
Intimate performances of solos by conductor
(* = Excellent, ** = Best) (colors indicate conductors with more than one of the three)
| Christie | Laudamus | Et |
|---|---|---|
| Gönnenwein | Fricsay ** | Jochum |
| Gardiner** | Gönnenwein | Paumgartner |
| Shaw | Karajan | Davis |
| Levine | Welser-Möst | Gardiner** |
| Kuentz | Hogwood | Bertini |
| Bernstein | Neumann | Shaw (“the trill”) |
| Vad* | Corboz | Welser-Möst |
| Christie | Solti | Levine |
| Matt | Rilling 1991 | Kuentz |
| McCreesh | Parrott | Neumann |
| Langreé | Marriner* | Corboz |
| Christophers | Vad | Bernstein* |
| Suzuki* | Girolami | Rilling 1991* |
| Christie* | Herreweghe | |
| Bolton* | Parrott | |
| Langreé | Marriner | |
| Suzuki | Vad | |
| Bernius* | Halász | |
| Arman | Christie | |
| Matt | ||
| McCreesh | ||
| Helmpfling | ||
| Christophers | ||
| Suzuki | ||
| Bernius | ||
| Arman |
NEXT: ENSEMBLES
